Creatine & Caffeine: What We Found Makes These Pre-Workout Supplements Worthless

Combining creatine with caffeine is a very bad idea.  While most supplement combine the two, this is not very smart at all.  For this will decrease the effectiveness of the creatine.  Below you will see proof from the largest manufacturer of creatine in the world, emailing me, explaining that you should not combine creatine & caffeine.

When it comes to formulating supplements, do we really know who is behind them? Not really, but we can only hope that the companies and/or people formulating these supplements have some shred of intelligence.  Unfortunately, many do not and the pre-workout supplements are probably the worst formulated supplements that you can buy.  Why do I say that?  Well here are two FACTS that you cannot dispute that makes MOST pre-workout supplements completely useless.

1) Caffeine negates the effects of Creatine.  And this is backed up by the world’s highest quality Creatine manufacturer…ALZCHEM, which makes Creapure.  Check out this email they sent me when I asked them about caffeine and creatine


 

From: Loeber,  [[email protected]]

Sent: Wednesday, April 03, 2015 10:49 AM

To: Carmody

Subject: AW: [Creapure Contact Form DE]

Dear Alex,

We recommend to wait appr. 2 h between the consumption of caffeine and creatine.

Best regards,

Verena

Verena Löber

______________________

Sales Manager Nutrition

T +49 8621 86-26

AlzChem AG

83308 Trostberg

Germany

http://www.alzchem.com

http://www.creapure.com

Screen Shot 2015-05-24 at 7.42.01 AM


 

In addition to the email above, you can find numerous studies that show taking caffeine with creatine is a bad idea.

Here are some

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8929583

and the conclusion of the study clearly states

The data shows that Cr supplementation elevates muscle PCr concentration and markedly improves performance during intense intermittent exercise. This ergogenic effect, however, is completely eliminated by caffeine intake.

 

 

2) Taking Creatine POST-WORKOUT is better.  Here is a study that clearly states taking creatine POST-workout is better than pre-workout. Here is the conclusion

Conclusions

Creatine plus exercise increases mass and strength. Creatine post-workout is superior to pre” “Creatine supplementation plus resistance exercise increases fat-free mass and strength. Based on the magnitude inferences it appears that consuming creatine immediately post-workout is superior to pre-workout vis a vis body composition and strength.”

Now here’s my question.  Why is it that MOST of the pre-workout supplements being sold today contain caffeine and creatine?  It makes absolutely no sense.  But let me tell you why I think that supplement companies use creatine and caffeine in their pre workouts.

The first reason is supplement companies think that people want that JACKED up feeling pre-workout.  And it is true…they do.  Why?  Not sure…me personally I don’t like that feeling and to me..if I need caffeine to get amped up for my workout…then that tells me something is wrong with my diet.

Second reason is the “kitchen sink” theory of mine.  It basically says that people look at the back of the ingredient label on a supplement, if it looks impressive…meaning it has this and it has that and more of this, and oh yea has me some of that…people will buy it.

Bottom Line:

  • Don’t buy a pre-workout with creatine
  • Don’t buy a pre-workout with caffeine
  • Use creatine POST-workout
  • Don’t use caffeine with creatine

Here are some brands of pre-workout I do NOT recommend because they contain creatine and caffeine.

  1. Jym (uses caffeine and creatine) and this Jim Stopanni is supposedly some sort of supplement expert?? 🙁
  2. ON (used caffeine and creatine)

Gold Standard Pre-Workout by Optimum Nutrition at Bodybuilding.com - Lowest Prices on Gold Standard Pre-Workout! 2015-05-24 07-55-07

  1. NO explode
  2. Muscle Pharm.

The hell with it…I’ll stop listing because there are too many. It seems they all have caffeine and creatine….just be really careful and read your label.

Comments

comments